(c) 2019 Jon L Gelman, All Rights Reserved.

Friday, February 22, 2019

Legislation to Reduce Violence in Workplace

Congressman Joe Courtney (CT-02), a senior Member of the House Education and Labor Committee, introduced legislation this week to curb rising rates of workplace violence facing health care and social service employees such as nurses, physicians, emergency responders, medical assistants, and social workers. The Workplace Violence Prevention for Health Care and Social Service Workers Act (H.R. 1309) is co-sponsored by Congressman Robert C. “Bobby” Scott (VA-03), Chairman of the House Education and Labor Committee, Congresswoman Alma Adams (NC-12), Chairwoman of the Subcommittee on Workforce Protections, as well as by 24 other Members of Congress. The bill directs the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) to issue a standard requiring health care and social service employers to write and implement a workplace violence prevention plan to prevent and protect employees from violent incidents in the workplace.
Congressman Joe Courtney

“Health care and social service workers face a disproportionate amount of violence at work, and the data shows that these incidents are on the rise,” said Congressman Courtney. “Safety experts, employees, and Members of Congress have been pressing OSHA to address this outsized risk of violence for years, but have seen no meaningful action. This legislation is the result of a five-year process to build the foundation for long overdue change to protect America’s caring professions, and would require OSHA to issue a Workplace Violence Prevention Standard, giving workers the security that their employers are implementing proven practices to reduce the risk of violence on the job. With the Committee’s announcement just yesterday of a hearing next week on protecting health care and social workers from workplace violence, we can be assured that this bill is finally poised to move, and not just sit on the shelf.”

“Workplace violence against health care and social service workers continues to threaten those who dedicate their lives to caring for others,” said Chairman Scott. “This bill helps address this growing problem by requiring the Occupational Safety and Health Administration to set an enforceable standard that will protect workers from preventable acts of workplace violence. I am grateful to Rep. Courtney for his leadership on this bill and look forward to discussing this and other solutions at next week’s hearing on workplace safety.”

“Every year, more than 850 workers are killed on the job and another 28,000 suffer serious injury”, said Congresswoman Adams. “The Workplace Violence Prevention and Social Services Workers Act sends the message that ‘enough is enough’ — setting a national standard that forces employers to take seriously the health and safety of American workers. I am proud to stand with Rep. Courtney and Chairman Scott in support of this effort, and look forward to its consideration by the House.”

“Health care and social service workers provide care to some of the most vulnerable in our society,” said Congressman John Larson (CT-01). “However, they can be at risk for workplace violence due to their unique roles. I am proud to join Congressman Courtney to ensure these workers are protected from preventable harm.” 

“Health care and social service workers face some of the highest rates of workplace violence,” said Congressman Ro Khanna (CA-17). “Violence in any workplace is unacceptable. These workers have dedicated their careers to helping others and deserve to go to work each day with a reasonable expectation of their own safety. I’m proud to partner with Reps. Joe Courtney and Bobby Scott, chairman of the House Education and Labor Committee, to follow my home state of California’s lead and pass this overdue, common sense legislation.” 

Incidents of violence against health care and social service workers is on the rise. A 2016 GAO study reported that rates of violence against health care workers are up to 12 times higher than rates for the overall workforce, and 70% of nonfatal workplace assaults in 2016 occurred in the health care and social assistance sectors. Recently released data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics found a sharp increase in serious injuries as a result of workplace violence among health care workers last year. Front line employees in these settings interact with a range of patients, clients, and their families, often with little training or direction for how to prevent or handle interactions that become violent. The Workplace Violence Prevention in Health Care and Social Services Act would ensure that health care and social service workplaces adopt proven prevention techniques and are prepared to respond in the tragic event of a violent incident.  

In 2013, Courtney requested that the Government Accountability Office study the trends in healthcare workplace violence and identify options for OSHA to curtail it, and in 2016 he and other members asked OSHA to develop a workplace safety standard to protect health care workers from this rising violence. In recent years, OSHA agreed to undergo rulemaking on health care workplace violence, but action has stalled under the Trump Administration. In the absence of voluntary action from OSHA, this legislation is necessary to ensure that nurses, doctors, medical assistants, emergency personnel, and social service workers are not subjected to needless preventable acts of violence on the job.  

On Wednesday, February 27, the Education and Labor Committee’s Subcommittee on Workforce Protections will hold a hearing entitled, “Caring for our Caregivers: Protecting Health Care and Social Service Workers from Workplace Violence.” Click here for more information.

Upon introduction, Congressman Courtney’s Workplace Violence Prevention for Health Care and Social Service Workers Act received support from a host of health care and social service professionals, as well as unions representing workers in these sectors. A full list of supporting organizations and their endorsements can be viewed below:

Randi Weingarten – President, American Federation of Teachers: “Our nurses and health industry workers care every day for the sick, the elderly and the mentally ill, yet they often feel unsafe or unprotected themselves from the assaults that occur in hospitals and other healthcare-related settings. While the Occupational Safety and Health Administration has left these workers vulnerable, incidents of workplace violence continue to rise with 69 percent of reported cases occurring in healthcare settings. Thankfully, this bill addresses this increasing trend head-on and provides long-needed protections and specific and enforceable safety standards for people who work in front-line healthcare jobs.

Jean Ross, RN – Co-President, National Nurses United: “As nurses who work at the bedside, our union has seen violence reach epidemic proportions in our hospitals and clinics. Employers’ failure to prevent violence not only harms nurses and other healthcare workers, but it harms our patients too. That’s why our union fought for—and won—a landmark workplace violence prevention standard in California and why we applaud Rep. Courtney for moving forward legislation to create comprehensive federal protections for nurses and other healthcare professionals against violence on the job. We know that violence can be prevented when employers establish plans that are tailored to fit the risks at each workplace and each patient care unit with the input of nurses and other workers at the bedside. Nurses look forward to working with Congress on the Workplace Violence Prevention for Health Care and Social Service Workers Act, and we encourage every Representative to cosponsor this legislation.”

Richard L. Trumka – President, AFL-CIO: "Workplace violence is a serious safety and health problem that has reached epidemic levels. Nurses, medical assistants, emergency responders and social workers face some of the greatest threats, suffering more than 70% of all workplace assaults. With no federal OSHA standard in place, the problem is growing, but the Trump administration has refused to act. We applaud the introduction of the Workplace Violence Prevention for Health Care and Social Service Workers Act by Rep. Joe Courtney to force action to protect our caregivers from unnecessary injuries and death."

Angelo McClain, PhD, LICSW – Chief Executive Office of the National Association of Social Workers: “The National Association of Social Workers is proud to support the Workplace Violence Prevention for Health Care and Social Service Workers Act. This bill is a crucial step in reducing the staggering number of preventable physical and psychological assaults on social workers and other health and social services professionals. NASW supports these and other measures to protect these professionals, who provide a wide range of critically needed services in increasingly complex and dangerous settings.”

Ernest Grant, PhD, RN, FAAN – President, American Nurses Association: “The American Nurses Association, representing the nation’s 4 million registered nurses, is indebted to the members of Congress who remain steadfast in championing this critical legislation. We believe in this bill because it underscores the urgency to address existing workplace cultures that discourage nurses from reporting for fear of retribution and to implement plans that prevent incidence of violence in the workplace. Safe work environments and quality care are not mutually exclusive, both must be considered in order to promote positive health outcomes for patients and communities. This bill is a step towards meaningful progress to prevent incidents of violence in all health care settings and we thank Rep. Courtney for introducing this legislation.”

Mary Florio – President, AFSCME Affiliate Connecticut Health Care Associates: “As a Registered Nurse, I have experienced an assault while tending to a patient. The statistics prove what we already knew. Workplace violence is an ongoing and growing problem for health care professionals. Our coworkers in emergency rooms and behavioral health care facilities regularly interact with patients and their families who are acting out and may become violent.”

“Short staffing and limited trained security staff drastically increase the potential for a staff member who is providing care to be assaulted and injured. We will continue to be a voice in developing and implementing legislation needed to protect our co-workers. We applaud Congressman Joe Courtney’s ongoing efforts to address this issue and support his legislation to address these issues.”

Martha Baker, RN – Chairperson, Nurse Alliance of SEIU Healthcare: “No healthcare worker should fear the threat of violence and injury while at work caring for others. The 80,000 registered nurse members of the Nurse Alliance of SEIU Healthcare have a long history of advocating for quality care standards and safer workplaces for all nurses and healthcare workers. This legislation, which directs the Occupational Health and Safety Administration to issue a workplace violence prevention standard, is an important first step to ensure our healthcare employers provide a safe environment where workers, patients and families are protected from preventable violence.”

Patricia Kunz Howard, PhD, RN, CEN, CPEN, TCRN, NE-BC, FAEN, FAAN – President, Emergency Nurses Association: “Emergency nurses should never fear going to work. They should not have their focus on patient care disrupted by worries of being punched, kicked or choked. ENA strongly supports legislative efforts which aim to mitigate the epidemic of violence in the emergency department, empower nurses to report violent incidents with confidence, and ensure the ED is a safe environment where emergency nurses think solely about their commitment to care without concerns about being victimized.”

Leo W. Gerard – President, United Steel Workers International: “We applaud the introduction of this bill requiring OSHA to finally address the epidemic of workplace violence against health care and social service workers. For too long, our members working across health care settings and job classifications have lived with the knowledge that they could fall victim to violence just by doing their jobs. Workplace violence is preventable, and our union supports this bill.”

Shanna Devine – Worker Health and Safety Advocate, Public Citizen’s Congress Watch Division: “Health care and social service workers are on the frontlines of keeping patients safe, often at great risk to themselves. It is inexcusable that the very workers who care for our loved ones also experience the highest rates of workplace violence. With reports of violence on the rise, we cannot afford to wait while OSHA drags its feet on regulatory protections. Congress must advance this critical legislation without delay.”


Jon L. Gelman of Wayne NJ is the author of NJ Workers’ Compensation Law (West-Thomson-Reuters) and co-author of the national treatise, Modern Workers’ Compensation Law (West-Thomson-Reuters). For over 4 decades the Law Offices of Jon L Gelman  1.973.696.7900  has been representing injured workers and their families who have suffered occupational accidents and illnesses.

Wednesday, February 20, 2019

An Unpaid Volunteer Firefighter Is Entitled to NJ Workers’ Compensation Temporary Benefits

The NJ Supreme Court unanimously held that an unpaid and unemployed volunteered firefighter was entitled to temporary workers’ compensation benefits. The Court, in reversing both the Trial and Appellate rulings, declared that volunteer firefighters have been conferred special status by the New Jersey legislature and they should be paid temporary disability benefits at the maximum rate without a seven-day waiting period, even if the injured volunteer firefighter was not holding outside employment at the time of the work-related injury. 

The court rationalized, that even if there appeared to be ambiguity the Workers’ Compensation Act, the Court would look to extrinsic evidence including the legislative history, committee reports and contemporary and he is construction in reaching its decision. The Court recognized that the Workers' Compensation Act is ”remedial legislation and should be given a liberal interpretation so its beneficent and purpose maybe accomplish.” 

The New Jersey legislature in enacting N.J.S.A. 34:15-75 codified that maximum compensation rates are payable to injured volunteer firefighters and that they are not subject to the seven-day waiting period for temporary disability benefits. The Court also noted the important role volunteer firefighters played in New Jersey has been recognized by the Legislature who encouraged formation and maintenance because of the great benefits conferred upon the municipalities hi the volunteer fire company. 

Justice Timpone, who delivered the opinion, stated, “In sum, the extrinsic evidence and legislative history decidedly indicate the Legislature intended to increase temporary disability coverage for volunteer firefighters injured in the course of performing their duties when it enacted the current form of N.J.S.A. 34:15-75, and not create new barriers to coverage. As such, we find N.J.S.A. 34:15-75 authorizes all volunteer firefighters injured in the course of performing their duties to receive the maximum compensation permitted, regardless of their outside employment status at the time of injury.” 

Galen W. Booth argued the cause for appellant (Law Offices of Galen W. Booth, attorneys; Galen W. Booth and Peter Ventrice, of counsel and on the briefs). 

Jennifer A. Cottell argued the cause for respondent (Capehart & Scatchard, attorneys; Jennifer A. Cottell, on the briefs, and John H. Geaney, of counsel and on the briefs). 

Jeffrey S. Monaghan argued the cause for amicus curiae New Jersey Association for Justice (Pellettieri, Rabstein & Altman, attorneys; Jeffrey S. Monaghan, on the brief). 

Pablo N. Blanco submitted a brief on behalf of amicus curiae New Jersey Advisory Council on Safety and Health (The Blanco Law Firm, attorneys). 

Kocanowski v Township of Bridgewater, ___ NJ ____ (2019), 2019 WL 661164 (Decided February 19, 2019).


Jon L. Gelman of Wayne NJ is the author of NJ Workers’ Compensation Law (West-Thomson-Reuters) and co-author of the national treatise, Modern Workers’ Compensation Law (West-Thomson-Reuters). For over 4 decades the Law Offices of Jon L Gelman  1.973.696.7900  has been representing injured workers and their families who have suffered occupational accidents and illnesses.

Sunday, January 20, 2019

Six-Year Statute of Limitations Governs Medical Claims

In a landmark decision the NJ Court of Appeals held that medical provider claims for expenses in workers’ compensation claims are subject to a contractual six-year statute of limitations. The ruling will have a major impact upon the overburdened state’s Division of Workers’ Compensation (NJDWC) system.

The NJDWC is already recognizing a soaring number of medical expense disputes and it lacks a standardized adjudication process. The Legislature should establish a medical fee schedule and create a separate alternate dispute resolution (ADR) system to adjudicate the medical provider claims.

Tuesday, January 8, 2019

Class Action case advances against Cigna for alleged medical overcharging scheme

A class of patients who allege that they were overcharged for needed medical services including: blood tests, drugs and durable goods, filed a class action lawsuit recently. The Court handling the case has ruled that the case can proceed against Cigna Health and Life Insurance Co. (CIGNA).

Friday, January 4, 2019

Landlord Held Not Liable for Injuries Of Tenant's Employee

A NJ Appellate Court has upheld the summary judgment dismissing the case where a commercial landlord was sued in a civil action for damages injured by a tenant's employee. The Court reasoned that the tenant had exclusive possession of the premises under the lease and the tenant had sole responsibility for the maintenance and repair of the premises.

US EPA Continues to Shield the Asbestos Industry

Trump EPA Moves To Shield Info on Asbestos Imports and Use From Public

The Trump administration has denied a petition by a coalition of environmental groups calling for increased reporting of asbestos importation and use by U.S. manufacturers – despite a sharp rise in asbestos imports into U.S. ports.

Monday, December 31, 2018

Nebraska Doctor Exposed to New Ebola Outbreak

An American providing medical assistance in the Democratic Republic of Congo recently experienced a possible exposure to the Ebola virus and is in Omaha for monitoring. This person has no Ebola symptoms but will be monitored closely. Should any symptoms develop, the Nebraska Biocontainment Unit would be activated and the person admitted.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...