Copyright

(c) 2010-2026 Jon L Gelman, All Rights Reserved.

Saturday, November 21, 2026

No Standing, Asbestos Ban Stands

The Fifth Circuit dismissed every challenge to EPA’s chrysotile asbestos ban. The rule survives, the workers’ claims keep coming, and legacy asbestos remains unregulated.



On November 19, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit dismissed all of the petitions for review in Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (consolidated with No. 24-60281), for lack of jurisdiction. Judge Kurt D. Engelhardt wrote for a panel that included Judges Edith Brown Clement and Leslie H. Southwick. The court never reached the merits. No petitioner, not the chemical industry, not the United Steelworkers, and not the public health and firefighter coalition, proved Article III standing at the time and in the manner the court required.

The practical result is that EPA’s 2024 Asbestos Part 1 rule banning the remaining ongoing uses of chrysotile asbestos stands exactly as written. It is the first asbestos ban under the Toxic Substances Control Act to outlast an appellate challenge, and it does so in the same court that vacated EPA’s 1989 ban in Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA, 947 F.2d 1201 (5th Cir. 1991). That is a fitting irony. The Fifth Circuit also decided Borel v. Fibreboard Paper Products Corp., 493 F.2d 1076 (5th Cir. 1973), the insulator’s case that opened the modern era of asbestos litigation. This post follows my June report from the oral argument.

The Rule Under Review

Section 6(a) of TSCA, 15 U.S.C. § 2605, directs EPA to regulate chemicals that present an unreasonable risk of injury to health. Relying on that authority, EPA’s Final Rule, 89 Fed. Reg. 21970 (Mar. 28, 2024), prohibits the manufacture, import, processing, distribution, and commercial use of chrysotile asbestos in chlor-alkali diaphragms, sheet gaskets, oilfield brake blocks, aftermarket brakes, and other gaskets, on phase-out schedules running from months to years. EPA tied chrysotile exposure to mesothelioma, lung, laryngeal, and ovarian cancer, and to asbestosis. The rule survived a 2025 reconsideration effort, which EPA abandoned in July of that year, as I reported then.

The challengers came from opposite directions. The chemistry councils argued the ban went too far for chlor-alkali and chemical production. The Steelworkers argued EPA unlawfully gave interim protections to titanium-dioxide workers but not to other chemical workers who install and remove asbestos sheet gaskets. The advocacy petitioners, led by the Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization and the American Public Health Association, argued EPA did not ban enough fiber types and uses. The issues are summarized in my September 2025 post, Asbestos Ban Under Fire.

Three Petitioners, Three Failures

The panel applied a demanding rule. On direct review of agency action, a petitioner carries a burden similar to summary judgment and must support standing with record evidence, not allegations, citing Shrimpers & Fishermen of RGV v. TCEQ, 968 F.3d 419 (5th Cir. 2020), and Clapper v. Amnesty International USA, 568 U.S. 398 (2013). From those precedents the court drew a firm timing rule: a petitioner who is not sure the record proves its standing must submit affidavits with its opening brief, not after the court raises the question.

•       Industry. The chemistry councils devoted a sentence to standing and claimed it was self-evident because their members are directly regulated. The court rejected that. Olin Corporation, the directly regulated company in the case, withdrew in May 2026. The record did not show which companies belonged to which association when the petitions were filed in 2024. Evidence that Occidental Chemical belonged to the American Chemistry Council during the rulemaking was not enough. In the court’s words, “we don’t fill in the blanks for petitioners.”

•       The Steelworkers. The union raised standing only in a footnote, and footnote arguments are forfeited in the Fifth Circuit. More fundamentally, it described thousands of exposed gasket workers but never identified a single one. Under Summers v. Earth Island Institute, 555 U.S. 488 (2009), an association must name the members who are harmed.

•       Firefighters and public health groups. Only this group filed standing evidence on time, and it still lost. IAFF Local F-253 cited NIOSH data showing firefighters have twice the general population’s mesothelioma rate, but the court called its claim of increased risk vague conjecture, not certainly impending harm. APHA’s members only “may be exposed.” ADAO, which has supporters rather than members, failed the indicia-of-membership test derived from Hunt v. Washington State Apple Advertising Commission, 432 U.S. 333 (1977).

The court refused every post-argument declaration, treating standing as the “bedrock constitutional requirement” described in FDA v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, 602 U.S. 367 (2024). It expressly declined to say anything about the merits.

The Court’s Rationale

The opinion is a procedural decision with substantive consequences. It establishes in the Fifth Circuit that the self-evident-standing exception, borrowed from D.C. Circuit practice, protects only a petitioner who could reasonably believe the administrative record itself proved its standing. Trade associations whose membership rolls are not in the record cannot make that claim. Unions and health organizations must name names. And the general proposition that a weaker rule leaves people at greater risk of asbestos disease does not establish injury in fact.

Because the challenge to the ban and the challenge to its gaps both failed, the status quo wins. For industry, that means the chlor-alkali phase-out continues. For workers’ advocates, it means the gaps they identified, including the gasket workers without interim protection, will not be closed by this court.

What It Means for Workers’ Compensation

The ban survives, and over the long run fewer new chrysotile exposures should mean fewer occupational disease claims. But asbestos disease carries a latency of decades. The ban does nothing for workers already exposed, and the opinion highlights several pressure points for the compensation system.

Risk is not a claim, anywhere. The federal courts would not recognize an increased risk of asbestos disease as an injury. Workers’ compensation draws the same line from the other side. Under N.J.S.A. 34:15-31, a compensable occupational disease must be due in a material degree to causes characteristic of the employment, and under N.J.S.A. 34:15-34 the limitations period runs from the worker’s knowledge of the disease and its relation to work. A worker exposed today has no regulatory forum to demand protection and no compensation forum until disease appears, often 20 to 40 years later. That gap is where exposure records disappear and employers dissolve.

Gasket workers become future claimants. The Steelworkers’ challenge would have extended interim exposure controls to chemical-plant workers who install and remove asbestos sheet gaskets. That challenge is gone. Those workers will continue to be exposed through the phase-out, and EPA’s own findings of unreasonable risk will be part of the evidentiary record if their disease claims, or claims of an employer’s knowing exposure under Millison v. E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co., 101 N.J. 161 (1985), come to court.

Firefighters still depend on presumptions. Local F-253’s evidence of doubled mesothelioma rates was not enough for Article III. It is, however, the kind of epidemiology that supports the state firefighter cancer presumptions that now carry these claims, including New Jersey’s Canzanella Act provisions in the Workers’ Compensation Law. When federal regulation stalls, the presumption becomes the primary protection, and municipal employers and carriers bear the cost.

Legacy asbestos is the real claims engine. The Part 1 rule addresses only ongoing uses of chrysotile. The asbestos that injures building trades, maintenance, demolition, and school workers today is already in place. EPA found legacy asbestos presents an unreasonable risk in December 2024, missed its statutory deadline for a Part 2 rule, was sued by ADAO in April 2026 (see my post, EPA Sued Over Asbestos), and has since sought to push its proposal to June 3, 2027. Until that rule exists, compensation remains the main remedy for legacy exposure.

A lesson for practitioners. The opinion is a reminder familiar to every compensation lawyer: proof must be in the record at the start. Named workers, sworn declarations, and documented exposure win cases. Generalized risk does not.

The Bottom Line

Thirty-five years after Corrosion Proof Fittings wiped out the 1989 ban, the Fifth Circuit has let the 2024 ban stand, not by approving it, but by finding no one properly before the court. The ban’s survival is good news for the next generation of workers. For the current generation, the legacy of asbestos will continue to be measured in workers’ compensation claims, mesothelioma diagnoses, and widows’ dependency petitions.

Sources

1.     Texas Chemistry Council v. EPA, No. 24-60193 (5th Cir. Nov. 19, 2026) (slip opinion)

2.     Asbestos Part 1; Chrysotile Asbestos; Regulation of Certain Conditions of Use Under TSCA, 89 Fed. Reg. 21970 (Mar. 28, 2024)

3.     Toxic Substances Control Act § 6, 15 U.S.C. § 2605

4.     Corrosion Proof Fittings v. EPA, 947 F.2d 1201 (5th Cir. 1991)

5.     Borel v. Fibreboard Paper Products Corp., 493 F.2d 1076 (5th Cir. 1973)

6.     Shrimpers & Fishermen of RGV v. Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, 968 F.3d 419 (5th Cir. 2020)

7.     Clapper v. Amnesty International USA, 568 U.S. 398 (2013)

8.    Summers v. Earth Island Institute, 555 U.S. 488 (2009)

9.     Hunt v. Washington State Apple Advertising Commission, 432 U.S. 333 (1977)

10.  FDA v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine, 602 U.S. 367 (2024)

11.   Millison v. E.I. du Pont de Nemours & Co., 101 N.J. 161 (1985)

12.  New Jersey Workers’ Compensation Law, N.J.S.A. 34:15-1 et seq. (N.J. Dep’t of Labor & Workforce Dev. compilation)

13.  Complaint, ADAO v. Zeldin, No. 1:26-cv-01350 (D.D.C. filed Apr. 21, 2026)

14.  ADAO, EPA Delays Part 2 Asbestos Rule Until 2027 (June 24, 2026)

15.  Jon L. Gelman, Asbestos at the Fifth Circuit (June 2, 2026)

16.  Jon L. Gelman, EPA Sued Over Asbestos (Apr. 25, 2026)

17.   Jon L. Gelman, Asbestos Ban Under Fire (Sept. 2025)

18.  Jon L. Gelman, Asbestos Ban: A Win for Workers (July 11, 2025)

Recommended Citation

Jon L. Gelman, No Standing, Asbestos Ban Stands, Workers’ Compensation (workers-compensation.blogspot.com) (Nov. 20, 2026), https://workers-compensation.blogspot.com/2026/11/no-standing-asbestos-ban-stands.html.

About the Author

Jon L. Gelman of Wayne, NJ, is the author of NJ Workers’ Compensation Law (West-Thomson-Reuters) and co-author of the national treatise Modern Workers’ Compensation Law (West-Thomson-Reuters).

Blog: Workers’ Compensation

LinkedIn: JonGelman

LinkedIn Group: Injured Workers Law & Advocacy Group

Author: “Workers’ Compensation Law” West-Thomson-Reuters

Blue Sky: jongelman@bsky.social

Substack: https://jongelman.substack.com/

© 2026 Jon L Gelman. All rights reserved.

Attorney Advertising

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Disclaimer

Download Adobe Reader