Copyright
Sunday, October 4, 2009
The Great Health Care Debate
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Medical Costs Soar in the US $55.4 Billion Workers’ Compensation Business
The costs of the workers’ compensation medical care nationally now represents 49% ($27.2 Billion) of the benefit package. Cash benefits grew a modest .8% over last year.
For about medical benefits and Workers’ Compensation click here.
Tuesday, September 15, 2009
The Urgent Need for Workers Compensation Flu Pandemic Planning
Thursday, September 10, 2009
Congressional Action on Workers’ Compensation
From coast to coast, the patchwork of state workers’ compensation systems continues to be under constant scrutiny for change. The problems seem global in characteristic as the frustrations continue to rise. The fate of the entire system may result in the effort to enact or defeat legislation to embrace a new national commission on workers’ compensation.
The States universally enacted Workers’ Compensation in 1911 in an effort to replace civil litigation with an administrative system. The approach was to provide a remedial system to injured workers in a summary manner while providing a cost effective approach for employers. Despite the efforts to reduce benefits and limit access States are struggling to maintain the system in one fashion or another. Rumors are spreading that New York, a former industrial jurisdiction, may join the list of radically modifying their system.
The once touted as a “no fault” system, the nation’s workers’ compensation has been besieged by efforts to assert more restrictive requirements for benefits. Medical delivery has stagnated in a complex world of etiology and evidential proof of occupational claims. The cost of soaring medical care, once shifted easily to collateral health insurance companies and the Social Security system, has been met with convoluted reimbursement efforts. Large corporations and public entities that in the past were able to provide an additional stream of revenue to injured workers are now rapidly drying up and or become non-existent under bankruptcy laws. State governments, that maintain the administrative system, are now facing a monumental shortage is revenue and are closing down operations and converting some for criminal and economic sanctions to merely benefit the general state revenues. The few remaining second injury funds have become insolvent and the future remains bleak as the premiums committed to finance these agencies and programs become depleted.
On January 22, 2009, Representative Joe Baca, a Democrat from California, introduced legislation (HR635) to establish a second National Commission on State Workers' Compensation Laws [Commission]. The first Commission was established under the Nixon administration in accordance with the Occupational Safety and Health Act. The new legislation that is now supported by representatives of injured workers lacks co-sponsors. Opposing the legislation is a long line of Industry based employers including the Americans Manufacturing Association and the National Chamber of Commerce.
John Burton, the former chair of the 1971 Commission, in a recent interview, commented that many of the present systems do not even comply with threshold recommendations of the original Commission and that many of the present programs face some serious challenges.
Patrice Woeppel, Ed.D., author of Depraved Indifference the Workers' Compensation System, has called for a single payer medical system to embrace both work and non-worker related injuries. By allowing the employer and insurance carrier to control the medical care she indicates, results in "restricting treatment to the cursorily palliative" or delay and denial of treatment to the injured worker. Additionally medical plan administrative costs of duplicative and wasteful.
As the national health care debate continues and the final legislation unfolds, the workers’ compensation medical delivery issues and wage replacements for temporary and permanent disability may become incorporated into direct or ancillary legislation. A second Commission, in one form or another, aimed at nationalizing the workers compensation system, may indeed become a reality.
Saturday, August 8, 2009
Congressional Committee Moves to Reopen Victims Compensation Fund
(2) initial health evaluation, monitoring, and treatment benefits to residents and other building occupants and area workers who were directly impacted and adversely affected by such attacks. Requires the WTC program administrator to:
(1) implement a quality assurance program;
(2) establish the WTC Health Program Scientific/Technical Advisory Committee;
(3) establish the WTC Responders Steering Committee and the WTC Community Program Steering Committee;
(4) provide for education and outreach on services under the WTC program;
(5) provide for the uniform collection of data related to WTC-related health conditions;
(6) conduct research on physical and mental health conditions that may be related to the September 11 terrorist attacks; and
(7) extend and expand arrangements with the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene to provide for the World Trade Center Health Registry. Authorizes the administrator to make grants to the Department to address mental health needs relating to the terrorist attacks.
Amends the Air Transportation Safety and System Stabilization Act to:
(1) make individuals eligible for compensation under the September 11 Victim Compensation Fund of 2001 for harm as a result of debris removal; and
(2) extend the deadline for making a claim for compensation.
Saturday, July 25, 2009
Injured Workers Assert Class Action Claiming Wal-Mart Violated RICO Act
Friday, July 24, 2009
Medical Provider Claims Viable RICO Action Against Insurance Company in Petition to US Supreme Court
George Schoedinger, et al., Petitioner v. United Healthcare of the Midwest, Inc, No. 09-80 (July 16, 2009) |
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Declining Salaries and Unemployment Challenege Workers' Compensation
Thursday, July 9, 2009
NCCI Reports Workers Compensation Claims Continue to Decline
"Preliminary results indicate a decline of 4.0% for 2008. This is on the heels of a 2.6% drop in claim frequency in 2007 and it extends a trend that started in the 1990s. While the overall decline is widespread .... high-cost Permanent Total claims have emerged recently as a noticeable exception to this decline."
The key finding of their analysis were:
- Over the last five years, there were significant declines in total lost-time claims frequency for all industries, geographic regions, and employer sizes
- The number and frequency of Permanent Total claims have increased significantly over the last four years, with all major causes of injury contributing to the rise
- The rise in Permanent Total claims appears to be driven primarily by workers age 50 or under
- While claim frequency generally decreases as risk size increases, single-state risks in some classes have higher claim frequency at the higher payroll sizes than at lower payroll sizes
Tuesday, June 30, 2009
Labor and Industry Join Forces to Change the Path of Health Care Delivery
The nation’s largest private employer, Walmart (non-union), and the nation’s largest union representing health care workers, SEIU, as well as the influential policy think-tank, the Center for American Progress, delivered a letter to President Obama today, endorsing a mandate for employer and employee contribution for a health care plan.
Citing the Senate Finance Committee (Max Bacus (D-Montana, Chairman) that “health care expenditures are expected to consume nearly 20 percent of the GDP” by 2017, the collation seek, “…an employer mandate which is fair and broad in its coverage.”
While the debate is being to flow in the direction of the adoption a “public plan” option, the “single payer system” has not yet been ruled out entirely. Funding continues to remain a concern.
It is anticipated that if a “public plan” is adopted, the workers’ compensation system will probably be targeted as an economic engine to contribute generated revenue through various reimbursement mechanisms in addition to outright payment reform including incentive based medicine. It is estimated that the plan's cost may amount to a $2 Trillion cost.
Cost shifting enforcement could be more strictly pursued. Additional fines, penalties and user fees, maybe assessed under the Medicare Secondary Payer Act. Even taxing workers’ compensation benefits may become an option if other employer provided health care benefits are also subject to tax.
Thursday, June 18, 2009
In-Home Care by Spouse Constitutes Treatment
Thursday, June 11, 2009
Vaccinating Workers’ Compensation Against Flu Claims
The spread of influenza A has now reached pandemic proportions. The focus has now been directed to creating a vaccine to halt the rapid community spread. The next challenge to workers’ compensation systems may be claims resulting from adverse reactions to employer sponsored vaccination programs.
For more on workers compensation and the flu pandemic visit the Workers' Compensation Blog.
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
The Lack of Equality in the CMS Reimbursement Policy
In a very insightful article, Robert Pear of The New York Times on June 9, 2009 reported that costs of medical care were not uniform through out the nation and that an increase in expenditures for treatment did not improve the outcome. These “disparities,” as Pear points out demonstrate major fluctuations in the cost of Medicare payments for the same types of treatment. “Nationally, according to the Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care, Medicare spent an average of $8,304 per beneficiary in 2006. Among states, New York was tops, at $9,564, and Hawaii was lowest, at $5,311.”
The costs for medical care paid by Medicare based upon geographical jurisdictions are unequal. More specifically, higher costs states were reported to be: Florida, Massachusetts, New Jersey and New York. The lower cost states were reported as: Iowa, Minnesota, Montana, North Dakota, Oregon and Washington.
CMS has sought to seek reimbursement under the MSP Act for medical care, present and future, based on a nationally tailored program. Unfortunately, the benefits paid by each state program are not the same.
While the program to deter the shift of billions of dollars Medicare funds yearly to pay for work related injuries and disease is a noble goal and legitimate function, it is now unequally applied to beneficiaries across the country since all workers’ compensation benefit programs are not the same and the costs of medical treatment vary.
The need for uniformity and equality should be address by Congress as it debates the future of medical care legislation. The enactment of a single payer medical care system would be a good first step to leveling the playing field for both employers and employees.
Saturday, June 6, 2009
Fixing The Broken Health Care System
In his weekly address to the nation The President said, "Simply put, the status quo is broken. We cannot continue this way. If we do nothing, everyone’s health care will be put in jeopardy. Within a decade, we’ll spend one dollar out of every five we earn on health care – and we’ll keep getting less for our money." Furthermore, "That’s why fixing what’s wrong with our health care system is no longer a luxury we hope to achieve – it’s a necessity we cannot postpone any longer."
The delivery of adequate medical benefits is a metastatic problem that goes to the very heart of the ability of the network of State workers' compensation system to operate. The costs of the delivery, co-ordination and administration of benefits continue to strangle the system into growing stagnation.
In a noble experiment the State of NJ, in response to critical reports, has proposed new regulations to establish an administrative system to expedite "emergent" medical benefits if an "irreparable harm" can be established. The irony is that the standard and requirement is so stringent, that imminent death does not even meet the standard.
The workers' compensation system was enacted in 1911, when the path was simple and short to provide medical care to "relieve and cure." The complexities that developed into the highway of benefits, has brought the major vehicle producers into bankruptcy, ie. Chrysler and General Motors. New vehicles will now need to be manufactured to meet the new needs of today and tomorrow.
It is time that Congress looks toward the workers' compensation system to develop a new vehicle to provide innovative approaches for a better medical delivery system for injured workers. A single medical care program that provides universal medical care would be a wise and appropriate route for America.
Thursday, May 21, 2009
Massive Coalition Seeks National Workers' Compensation Health Reform
Workers who are injured or made ill because of conditions at work face barriers to health
care access and receive inadequate benefits under separate state workers’ compensation
healthcare systems. Prevention and treatment of work-related health conditions should be
an integral component of comprehensive healthcare system reform."
Friday, May 15, 2009
A Brokered Marriage: Medicare and Workers’ Compensation
The Medicare Hospital Fund will be insolvent by 2017. The Trustees of the program have indicated that the program has been paying out more than it has collected in taxes and interest over the last two years. This estimated date of insolvency is two years ahead of schedule and the shortfall will necessitate a deposit of $13.4 trillion.
Robert Pear reported in the NY Times this week, “’The financial outlook for the hospital insurance trust fund is significantly less favorable than projected in last year's annual report,’ the trustees said, adding, ‘Actual payroll tax income in 2008 and projected future amounts are significantly lower than previously projected, due to lower levels of average wages and fewer covered workers.’”
The workers’ compensation medical delivery system has been plagued with a set of its own difficulties including: cost shifting to Medicare and reimbursement issues, rising costs that now exceed the indemnity aspect of the program, lack of uniformity and delay in delivery of medical benefits, staggering litigation and administrative costs and uncertainty as to future premiums because of a failing economy.
The voice of change is now being heard in Washington as health care takes the stage front and center on the issues of affordability and choice. David Axelrod has indicated that the Administration is committed to "fix what's broken in the system and preserve what's good."
When the Social Security system was initial enacted, the country faced similar economic troubles. Employee medical coverage was not a consideration of the original program. The geriatric nature of both the Social Security system and the multiple workers’ compensation programs are now evidencing the problems of old age. A marriage of convenience maybe just what the future holds.
Friday, May 8, 2009
NCCI Issues a “Guarded” Report of Health of Workers’ Compensation
Wednesday, May 6, 2009
US Congress to Hold Hearing on Helping Schools and Workplaces Prepare For Flu Virus
On Thursday, May 7, the Committee will hold a hearing to examine how federal agencies can help child care, schools, colleges and workplaces prepare for the H1N1 flu virus and future pandemics. The hearing will also provide an update on how schools and workplaces are being affected by and responding to the current outbreak.
WHAT: Hearing on “Ensuring Preparedness Against the Flu Virus at School and Work"
WHO:
Jordan Barab, Acting Assistant Secretary, Occupational Safety and Health Administration, Washington, DC
Ann Brockhaus, Occupational Safety and Health Consultant, ORC Worldwide, Washington, DC
Jack O'Connell, Superintendent of Public Instruction, California Department of Education, Sacramento, CA
Miguel Garcia, Registered Nurse and member, American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, Los Angeles, CA
Bill Modzeleski, Associate Assistant Deputy Secretary, Office of Safe and Drug-Free Schools, Department of Education, Washington, DC
Dr. Anne Schuchat, Deputy Director for Science and Program (Interim), Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, GA
WHEN: Thursday, May 7, 2009 10:00 a.m. ET
Please check the Committee schedule for potential updates »
WHERE: House Education and Labor Committee Hearing Room 2175 Rayburn House Office Building Washington, D.C.